Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[IndefinentBlu]

Originally Posted by O_V_N

Dude...You voted for the option in this thread that you were buying only the PT. LOL

I pre-ordered the COMPLETE SAGA when it was first announced I PREFER BOTH!!

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by Beta Man

Where does OVN or anyone else say you did?

That's what I'm wondering. I got accused too and I've kept my mouth shut on this thread for like a week...

[Chordata]

Originally Posted by indefinentnj

I have never voted in any of my polls ever and if it can be proven than show it if not than lets stop the kiddie games and get back to star wars.

Yeah actually I was dead wrong, my apologies. When you click the votes up top, I expected it to show me the people who voted for that particular selection. I read it wrong.

You voted for the entire trilogy, minus Empire since it puts you to sleep.

[Blu-Runner]

OT because of the characters. You can't beat Han Solo and Chewbacca. The PT takes the opposite direction with characters like Jar Jar Binks, Teenage Anakin, etc.

EDIT: Ahhh crap, and how could I forget Lando Calrissian...

[Beta Man]

Originally Posted by Blu-Runner

EDIT: Ahhh crap, and how could I forget Lando Calrissian...

[whbinder]

Originally Posted by indefinentnj

OKAY when have i ever said that i prefer the PT over the OT i have said i like then both. if anyone can stand here and prove to me that i said hey guys i like the PT better than i like the OT than come forward with proof not assumptions..

Please refrain from putting words in my mouth indefinentnj. I never said the 1993 Chicago Bulls were a better team than the 1996 Phoenix Suns.

[threefiftyrocket]

Originally Posted by indefinentnj

If you had to choose between the 2 trilogies which would you say is better and why??

Uh oh, I see Beast lurking around the corner waiting to strike on anyone that says the OT is better...

J/K man

[IndefinentBlu]

Originally Posted by whbinder

Please refrain from putting words in my mouth indefinentnj. I never said the 1993 Chicago Bulls were a better team than the 1996 Phoenix Suns.

What? does that mean. do i know you? have i ever said anything about you, or anyone around this site.

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by indefinentnj

What? does that mean. do i know you? have i ever said anything about you, or anyone around this site.

I think it's a joke. Or sarcasm.
Actually, I know it's a sarcastic joke.
It's a sarcastic joke, so it's not anything personal.

[IndefinentBlu]

Originally Posted by nathan_393

I think it's a joke. Or sarcasm.
Actually, I know it's a sarcastic joke.
It's a sarcastic joke, so it's not anything personal.

Well it seems that a lot of people thrive on that kind of sarcastic attention and like sometimes to resort to going behind ones back and saying stuff just like a delinquent does.

[Beta Man]

Let's get back on topic..... which is "Star Wars"

[Jay444]

Originally Posted by indefinentnj

Well it seems that a lot of people thrive on that kind of sarcastic attention and like sometimes to resort to going behind ones back and saying stuff just like a delinquent does.

Whoa, simmah down now! You are over-reacting. They are just kidding with you.

I prefer to OT, but can watch the PT without issue. But we might want to stay away from that conversation as it is sorta divisive is all.

[nathan_393]

Originally Posted by Jay444

Whoa, simmah down now! You are over-reacting. They are just kidding with you.

I prefer to OT, but can watch the PT without issue. But we might want to stay away from that conversation as it is sorta divisive is all.

Let's talk about Jar Jar instead

[Chordata]

How bout this: Give one thing you like and one thing you dislike about each movie. One thing only of each.

Me:

Phantom Menace:
Like - I never anticipated any movie ever like I anticipated this. It was so much fun leading up to the first midnight viewing (probably my first and last midnight viewing).
Dislike - Jake Lloyd. Poor kid; maybe he received bad direction.

Attack of the Clones:
Like - The battle between Obi-Wan and Jango.
Dislike - Some things that seem inconsistent or not well explained (to me), including Sifo-Dyas, Dooku, etc.

Revenge of the Sith:
Like - Seeing Vader finally get his suit.
Dislike - Wish we could've seen a closer relationship between Obi-Wan and Anakin or, alternatively, a bigger betrayal by Obi-Wan to make Anakin want to kill him.

A New Hope:
Like - Han Solo
Dislike - This one's hard...I guess the story lags after they escape the Death Star.

Empire Strikes Back:
Like - Hoth
Dislike - Dagobah

Return of the Jedi:
Like - Jabba's Palace
Dislike - Again, Dagobah. Story just drags there so much.

[Jay444]

Originally Posted by O_V_N

How bout this: Give one thing you like and one thing you dislike about each movie. One thing only of each.

THAT is a great idea: I built on it a bit to not just pick a bit on story but certain things about design or sound

TPM:
Like: Darth Maul's double bladed lightsaber.
Dislike: Jar Jar.

ATOC:
Like: Kamino (cool idea and a great design).
Dislike: Yoda grunts WAAAY too much in the fight against Dooku. If you ever wanted to know what Yoda sounds like while molesting a youngling, I am pretty sure that scene would give you an idea...

ROTS:
Like: Yoda's enterance to fight Sideous at the end, where he uses to force to take out those two guards. Badass.
Dislike: "She's lost the will to live..." Horrible.

ANH:
Like: The Tie Fighter/Falcon battle after Ben's Death.
Dislike: "I wanted to go to Toshi station..." such a whiney ***** of a line.

ESB:
Like: The Design of the Snow Trooper outfits. Just to put a spotlight on how EVIL the Empire really is, they made the Storm Stroopers look like clansman
Dislike: Yoda looks too much like a puppet when Luke is running with him on his back during the Degobah training

ROTJ:
Like: The Sarlacc pit fight, seriously, 4 minutes of awesome.
Dislike: Tie Fighters appearing out of thin air at the start of the Death Star attack.

[Dynamo of Eternia]

The Phontom Menace:
Like - The Ending Credits
Dislike - Everything that preceeds the ending credits.

[Chordata]

Ouch man! Don't cheat, though. To prevent this from becoming a PT-bashfest or an OT-bashfest, I'm forcing you to do each movie. How am I going to force you, you ask? Good question.

[Jay444]

Originally Posted by O_V_N

Ouch man! Don't cheat, though. To prevent this from becoming a PT-bashfest or an OT-bashfest, I'm forcing you to do each movie. How am I going to force you, you ask? Good question.

C'mon man, it is easy. Just do the following: *slowly wave your hand at him* and say: "You will answer the entire question."

[Chordata]

Originally Posted by Jay444

C'mon man, it is easy. Just do the following: *slowly wave your hand at him* and say: "You will answer the entire question."

Dude, he might be Toydarian!

[Batman1980]

Episode I -
Like - pretty much everything except
Dislike - Jar Jar and kiddie Anakin
Episode II -
Like - Jedi Order and Anakin as a padawan
Dislike - Anakin's emo-ness and the death of so many Jedi on Geonosis
Episode III -
Like - the climactic lightsaber duel and the turn of Anakin to the dark side
Dislike - Padme simply dying for no reason and Anakin's "noooooooooooo" scene
Episode IV -
Like - Old Ben talking to Luke and his repartee with Vader
Dislike - Pacing and relative lack of action in parts
Episode V -
Like - everything
Dislike - nothing
Episode VI -
Like - lightsaber duel on Death Star, Emperor using Force lightning
Dislike - Ewoks