Disney & HK film concerns

[zombie]

I really hope that Disney will discontinue their editing of Hong Kong films when they release them on Blu-ray. I always hated the various edits and title changes Disney did with the DVD releases of many martial arts films. For Jackie Chan's Armour Of God not only did they change the title but also released the sequel as the first film and the actual original film became the sequel. That's messed up! I hope Disney will have heard the various complaints by fans of films such as these and will not make these bonehead mistakes again with the future Blu-ray releases.

[thunderhawk]

I really hope that Disney will discontinue their editing of Hong Kong films when they release them on Blu-ray.

We'll have to wait till the Hong Kong film directed by Peter Jackson comes on BD 8)
No wait, New Line cinema is a ... :shock: Damn, HD-DVD disc...

[Gorkab]

Originally Posted by thunderhawk

We'll have to wait till the Hong Kong film directed by Peter Jackson comes on BD 8)
No wait, New Line cinema is a ... :shock: Damn, HD-DVD disc...

Yep and it's King Kong dude

[CodyCourtBlack2]

i think disney needs to find a way to make their full frame films widescreen without those paintings.

[svenge]

Originally Posted by PixarPerfect

i think disney needs to find a way to make their full frame films widescreen without those paintings.

The only way to do that would to be to crop off the top and bottom of the frame. That would be known in Blu-ray circles as a "bad thing". Try reading this thread:

https://forum.blu-ray.com/newbie-dis...y-threads.html

[The Blu Knight]

Originally Posted by PixarPerfect

i think disney needs to find a way to make their full frame films widescreen without those paintings.

Most TVs have a zoom feature which allows the average joe to bastardize a film's OAR as they please without condemning purists to butchered releases. You'll have to settle for that.

[steve_dave]

The Walt Disney Company had nothing to do with the alterations made to the Asian films that were released by Miramax and Dimension Films. Harvey Weinstein approved the alterations and Disney was opposed to changes made in several of those films.

The Weinstein Company was able to renegotiate the distribution deal for many of these films effectively moving them from the Disney owned Miramax/Dimension to the The Weinstein Company owned Miramax/Dimension. Some films remained at Disney and unfortunately, whiile Disney has the elements for these films, these are the edited versions produced by Miramax/Dimension.

You may also notice that a large majority of these former Miramax/Dimension releases are now appearing as Dragon Dynasty releases.Thankfully, The Weinstein Company has lost the distribution rights for a large percentage of the Fortune Star library.

I doubt we will ever see proper releases for all of these releases given that:

A) The Miramax/Dimension catalog of films that were in Disney's possession have been sold off. Meaning the new owners take ownership of the altered elements.

B) The Dragon Dynasty label is still alive thanks to Vivendi.

C) Harvey Weinstein could care less.

[toddly6666]

Which one do all you prefer: the original Hong Kong film or the newer Peter Jackson Hong Kong film?

[EricJ]

Originally Posted by steve_dave

The Walt Disney Company had nothing to do with the alterations made to the Asian films that were released by Miramax and Dimension Films. Harvey Weinstein approved the alterations and Disney was opposed to changes made in several of those films.

Aw, c'mon, don't you know the rules?:
Whenever Miramax has an Oscar nominee, it's Miramax's...
Whenever Miramax does something wrong with the fans, or hits controversy in the headlines, quote, "Disney did it again!!"

(Harvey had it put in their contract, Disney is only to assume full responsibility for Miramax's mistakes. )

I doubt we will ever see proper releases for all of these releases given that:
A) The Miramax/Dimension catalog of films that were in Disney's possession have been sold off. Meaning the new owners take ownership of the altered elements.
B) The Dragon Dynasty label is still alive thanks to Vivendi.
C) Harvey Weinstein could care less.

For said reason, I doubt we'll ever "eventually" see them on Blu-ray, either.