Still not convinced

[Doctorossi]

Originally Posted by bruceames.

It's funny to read about being a stickler for what's meant to be seen, while these same people have no qualms about the higher resolution making special effects look fake and revealing wires or other previously hidden objects.

There's a simple, practical difference:

If you want to watch a too-resolute disc at a lower resolution, you can just set your player to output a lower resolution.

If you want to watch an SDR movie in its proper color grade from an HDR disc, you're just out of luck.