CBS' "Elementary" (Season 4)

[jwerk]

Season premiere was pretty uneventful. The Gina Gershon character

[Show spoiler]was a complete waste. They could've made her a very interesting and worthy adversary for Joan.

It wasn't the best episode, but at least Sherlock is on tv again.

[Canada]

I have not seen Elementary at all, I was watching TV tonight and I stumbled across Elementary on Showcase and it happened to be the one where you find out that Irene Adler

[Show spoiler]is actually Moriarty.

[Moefiz]

Originally Posted by Canada

I have not seen Elementary at all, I was watching TV tonight and I stumbled across Elementary on Showcase and it happened to be the one where you find out that Irene Adler

[Show spoiler]is actually Moriarty.

I have been looking at this show since the first season, its not a bad show.Its can get repetitive week after week with the same type of cases, every once in awhile you will get a story arch that spans a few episodes thou.

[jayembee]

Originally Posted by Moefiz

I have been looking at this show since the first season, its not a bad show.Its can get repetitive week after week with the same type of cases, every once in awhile you will get a story arch that spans a few episodes thou.

I don't just think "it's not a bad show". I actually think it's a very good show. And as a Sherlock Holmes series, I actually prefer it to Sherlock. There are far too many times when Sherlock seems a bit too much like a fan-wank. I love Cumberbatch and Freeman, but I don't find the episodes them particularly interesting.

Elementary doesn't try to adhere to the letter of the Sherlock canon, but I think it's truer to the spirit of the Sherlock canon. Yes, sometimes the specific plots can be average, and it sometimes plays hob with characters from the canon, but at its best, I think the cases are very clever, and Johnny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu are very convincing as Holmes and Watson, and I find that I like them as those characters just as much as I like Cumberbatch and Freeman.