Bitstreaming takes away menu sounds and pip!

[solarrdadd]

Originally Posted by Trix

In regards to the emphasized section: Any player that can internally decode Doldy TrueHD and DTS HD-Master Audio can also internally decode secondary audio and then send the entire stream (HD Audio and Secondary audio) to a receiver as LPCM. It doesn't need to be the PS3, slim or fat.

I respectfully disagree. even the Oppo BDP-83, which i own, if secondary audio is enabled, it will mix the secondary audio with the primary HD audio, reducing it down in resolution to essentially "core" quality in LPCM. Check page 56 in the Oppo manual. Oppo is one of the newest, and one of, if not the best player(s) on the market and it cannot do this. I am not beyond saying i'm wrong. can you please list players, other than the
PS3 that can actually send lossless audio with secondary lossy audio, mixed in one stream? I could not find any; i'm not saying there might not be something incredibly new that i'm not aware of. i'm only speaking of what i currently am aware of. please list the brand and model of one that can do this. i think we would all like to know, we can all learn from this.