Malick's The New World

[StianG]

I'm a big fan of the theatrical cut of The New World, and was wondering if
there is any news on it getting released?

And what are the chances of Criterion releasing this? I assume they would release the Blu-ray with both cuts.

[James Luckard]

Originally Posted by StianG

I'm a big fan of the theatrical cut of The New World, and was wondering if
there is any news on it getting released?

And what are the chances of Criterion releasing this? I assume they would release the Blu-ray with both cuts.

But there are three cuts:

150 minutes - shown to critics in Dec 2005, released for 1 week in NY & LA Xmas Day 2005, sent to Academy and guild voters as a screener
135 minutes - wide release version
172 minutes - DVD extended cut

I think the 150 min version is the best. The 135 min version was whittled down way too far following hostile reviews, while the 172 minute version reinstates almost everything that was cut, but adds a large number of very strange jumpcuts in scenes throughout the film, which feel out of place in a period piece.

I'm glad to have my Italian DVD of the 150 min cut and won't buy a BD until it contains that version.

[Aragorn the Elfstone]

The extended cut is my preference over the theatrical, but I've never had the chance to see the 150 min cut (except for bits and pieces on youtube). I would love a Criterion edition that includes that version.

[MacEachaidh]

From what I've read, Malick prefers the 135 min cut.

But it seems to me the existing Blu-ray is a missed opportunity. It contains the longest cut, and there is no footage in either of the other two cuts that isn't in this version, so why could the disc not make all three cuts available for them as wanted 'em?

[James Luckard]

Originally Posted by MacEachaidh

there is no footage in either of the other two cuts that isn't in this version,

I'm not entirely sure that's true. At the very least, the jumpcuts mean there are bits and pieces not in the 172 min version. That said, it would be easy to do a seamless-branching version like the Alien movies...

Originally Posted by MacEachaidh

so why could the disc not make all three cuts available for them as wanted 'em?

My thoughts exactly. All three versions have been released commercially in various forms, so it's not like Malick refused to let them come out on video...

[s2mikey]

Originally Posted by SquidPuppet

Not to stir the pot, but this movie bored me to death. I was very eager in the months approaching its theatrical release, then snoozed. It certainly has the potential to look and sound great.

You arent the only one. It'll be nice to watch the pretty images on blu ray but dont look for much else.

[Variable_Star]

Originally Posted by James Luckard

I think the 150 min version is the best. The 135 min version was whittled down way too far following hostile reviews, while the 172 minute version reinstates almost everything that was cut, but adds a large number of very strange jumpcuts in scenes throughout the film, which feel out of place in a period piece.

Hmm interesting, I'll have to see that version. I've only ever seen the extended version and it's a film I have such a strong attachment to that I can't imagine removing much. I'd love to see what bits were removed and the overall flow of the 150 min. version.

[lemonski]

If you like The New World you really should have a read of this, it's very interesting

http://nonsite.org/issues/issue-2/te...icks-new-world

...and if you don't like The New World, it at least gives an insight into how carefully crafted Malick's films are

[Trekkie313]

Terrence needs to get his head out of the clouds literally and go back to "human" movies like this. No more stupid "Universe bullstuff".

[Falconer]

I think the cut on the blu-ray loses a bit of steam toward the end, but nevertheless, it's an incredible film.

[DetroitSquirreL]

Originally Posted by Trekkie313

Terrence needs to get his head out of the clouds literally and go back to "human" movies like this. No more stupid "Universe bullstuff".

This is why they make films by many generic directors, to please people like yourself. Malik has become one of my favorite directors BECAUSE he does his style that he does.

[jrsl76]

Finally picked this up and viewed it for the first time. It's a stunning movie. Rapturously beautiful really. Methodically paced, but engaging. I loved it. I'm watching the documentary now and it's fascinating, but I'm disappointed that Malick hasn't even appeared once in the docu.

[arcadeforest]

Originally Posted by jrsl76

Finally picked this up and viewed it for the first time. It's a stunning movie. Rapturously beautiful really. Methodically paced, but engaging. I loved it. I'm watching the documentary now and it's fascinating, but I'm disappointed that Malick hasn't even appeared once in the docu.

Yes, it's my favorite Malick film - very beautiful film.

[Tin Drum]

Originally Posted by jrsl76

Finally picked this up and viewed it for the first time. It's a stunning movie. Rapturously beautiful really. Methodically paced, but engaging. I loved it. I'm watching the documentary now and it's fascinating, but I'm disappointed that Malick hasn't even appeared once in the docu.

You expected him to show up?

I was fortunate to experience this wonderful film in the theater and it was so breathtakingly beautiful. I sat in my seat during the credits overwhelmed by the experience.

[The Great Owl]

I quickly upgraded of my Malick DVDs to Blu-ray after I bought my Blu-ray player in early December. Except, of course, Badlands, which I'm eagerly awaiting for the March release.

I had a blast enjoying the Blu-rays of Days of Heaven, The Thin Red Line, and The Tree of Life, but I've been watching them days apart to let each one sink in.

The New World Blu-ray is still waiting to be watched, and I'll probably watch it this weekend. It's my least favorite of the Malick films, but it's still 10,000 times better than the best work of most directors.

[toddly6666]

Originally Posted by arcadeforest

Yes, it's my favorite Malick film - very beautiful film.

my favorite Malick film as well - just love it!

[TheHighRoller]

Originally Posted by jrsl76

Finally picked this up and viewed it for the first time. It's a stunning movie. Rapturously beautiful really. Methodically paced, but engaging. I loved it. I'm watching the documentary now and it's fascinating, but I'm disappointed that Malick hasn't even appeared once in the docu.

Seeing him is like seeing a Big Foot sighting. Or if any of you have played Pokemon when you were younger: like one of the three legendary Pokemon that roam around and flee quickly when found.

I like that last analogy best, seeing as Malick is himself legendary.



As for The New World, I bought that and the score for The Social Network yesterday as part of the BBY 500 point promo. I've been meaning to buy it for a while, but I keep feeling like it will get a Criterion treatment. I don't know why though, seeing as the only Malick stuff that's released through Criterion is stuff that is recent (much like Wes Anderson's stuff). I kind of hope they go back and do some sort of Theatrical/Director's cut stuff with a 4K mastered transfer or something.

All I need now is Badlands so that I can see Malick's filmography in order in time for To the Wonder (and both The Untitled Terrence Malick Project, and Knight of Cups).

[The Great Owl]

Originally Posted by TheHighRoller

As for The New World, I bought that and the score for The Social Network yesterday as part of the BBY 500 point promo. I've been meaning to buy it for a while, but I keep feeling like it will get a Criterion treatment. I don't know why though, seeing as the only Malick stuff that's released through Criterion is stuff that is recent (much like Wes Anderson's stuff). I kind of hope they go back and do some sort of Theatrical/Director's cut stuff with a 4K mastered transfer or something.

All I need now is Badlands so that I can see Malick's filmography in order in time for To the Wonder (and both The Untitled Terrence Malick Project, and Knight of Cups).

I watched my Blu-ray of The New World the other night. It's the weak link in the Malick canon, in my opinion, but it's still a masterful film and an A+ across the board. I always get pretty emotional at the end.

I used to own the Warner DVD of Badlands, and I just about wore out that DVD from watching it so often. The Blu-ray should be shipping soon.

I really cannot wait to read the reviews of Badlands from posters here who have never seen the movie before. I think that all of you are in for a real treat.

[TheHighRoller]

Originally Posted by The Great Owl

I watched my Blu-ray of The New World the other night. It's the weak link in the Malick canon, in my opinion, but it's still a masterful film and an A+ across the board. I always get pretty emotional at the end.

I used to own the Warner DVD of Badlands, and I just about wore out that DVD from watching it so often. The Blu-ray should be shipping soon.

I really cannot wait to read the reviews of Badlands from posters here who have never seen the movie before. I think that all of you are in for a real treat.

I wish to own it before To the Wonder is released, but I honestly don't think I'll own it until B&N has another Criterion sale, in which case I'll be able to (hopefully) get it for $10.

I wish that the person who did the cover art for The Blob also did it for Badlands. I don't see why Criterion didn't make the Badlands art from stills/photography- especially since the other two Malick Criterion titles are like that.

[retablo]

Originally Posted by TheHighRoller

As for The New World, I bought that and the score for The Social Network yesterday as part of the BBY 500 point promo. I've been meaning to buy it for a while, but I keep feeling like it will get a Criterion treatment. I don't know why though, seeing as the only Malick stuff that's released through Criterion is stuff that is recent (much like Wes Anderson's stuff). I kind of hope they go back and do some sort of Theatrical/Director's cut stuff with a 4K mastered transfer or something.

You mean older, not recent. Criterion released his first 3 films. the newest 2 (New World and Tree of Life) aren't Criterion.

And they've released almost all the Wes Anderson films, recent or not (except for Life Aquatic and Fox).

Recent has nothing to do with either of these filmmakers in regards to Criterion's output.