BD SWOT Analysis: Will BD win the format war?

[ProvenFlipper]

Originally Posted by bdfan

Wouldn't that be another weakness: the fact that there has to be another disc for BD-J.
Does HD DVD's iHD need another disc as well.
Having two disc isn't a big deal but i heard that it turns some consumers off.

The second disc isn't because of BD-J, it's because Pirates is a 2.5 hr movie, and Disney is probably going to give us 24-bit PCM. In order to give us the best possible quality for audio and video, they are going to put the extras on a separate disc. Chicken Little has BD-J on the same disc as the movie, as does the Guardian. HD-DVD's HDi doesn't need a separate disc either.