FOX's "American Idol" (Season 16)

[TLeeTx2012]

Originally Posted by CZAR

I would love that final 3 and winner so I fully agree with u. Got Em!!

[Diesel]

That's the first time Haley actually looked sad

[Chloenator]

America finally got it right this week! Now we just need James gone!

Originally Posted by TLeeTx2012

Oh...is anyone here actually thinking about going to this season's Idol Live shows. I actually wouldn't mind going.

I'm thinking about going just to see Pia and Lauren. I'll wear ear plugs for Casey and James.

[JulieL]

SOOOOOO HAPPY with the results tonight. Now the other growler, Hayley, just needs to go!!!!

James & Lauren to the end!

[master_8ball]

Guess I'm rootin for James and Haley now.

[Diesel]

So glad they started seeing what Jimmy had to say about the performances.

Get that man a judge chair

[Mouse]

wow.. just wow. America has let me down. James is the only one left that deserves to win. Altho it will be acceptable if Lauren wins.

[crystal_sun]

Judges wasted their 1 saved pick on Casey....stupid judges using it too early... They should have used the saved for their top 3...hopefully, they learn from their mistake. I wish PIA was still around...miss that hottie. Personally, all the remaining contestants are boring...don't care who wins it...

[CZAR]

WOW!!!! What a shame!! I am so upset that Casey got voted off. America dont know who they just voted off. He will be a mega star in the future just watch!!! I am however glad that Haley wasnt even in the bottom 3. Hopefully she starts peaking her way to the finish because she is the only one I am rooting for now. I am also happy that Scotty made the bottom 3 and there is hope he can be eliminated very soon. So mixed feelings for tonight. Casey killed it at the end and went off like a tru showman and moved everyone. I almost had tears myself lol. Oh well we will hear from him again.

My Rankings
Haley Reinhart
James Durbin
Lauren Alaina
Jacob Lusk
Scotty McCreery

Got Em!!

[Diesel]

She might have been in the bottom 3. We don't know who was with Casey, Ryan announced at random.

[thelittleprince]

Originally Posted by crystal_sun

Judges wasted their 1 saved pick on Casey....stupid judges using it too early... They should have used the saved for their top 3...hopefully, they learn from their mistake. I wish PIA was still around...miss that hottie. Personally, all the remaining contestants are boring...don't care who wins it...

+1

Makes one wonder if the save would have been better used for Pia instead of Casey. Not a fan of Casey myself and the judges really blew it by using the save prematurely on him. Oh well. Rooting for James to win it all!

[TLeeTx2012]

Some of you just do not know what talent is...sad sad thing.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by Diesel

She might have been in the bottom 3. We don't know who was with Casey, Ryan announced at random.

Oh thats right huh? Well damn that doesnt make me feel to good. I actually like it better if they do it random anyway. That way we wont know who the popular ones are. Got Em!!

Originally Posted by TLeeTx2012

Some of you just do not know what talent is...sad sad thing.

+100 Got Em!!

[Diesel]

I kind of like the random too, it keeps you wondering who is actually at the bottom.

They should do that the whole way through.

[crystal_sun]

Winning! LOL....

It's not a talent show...it's a popularity contest... All the contestants can sing....just see who can grab more votes not based on their voice.

Originally Posted by TLeeTx2012

Some of you just do not know what talent is...sad sad thing.

[broganreynik]

Man, I'm all for James now that Casey is out, but he didn't do that well with the 30 Seconds to Mars song. Jacob sounded horrible as well. Lauren sounded better, but it wasn't that great. This late in the competition and their giving their worst performances, it's kind of a bummer.

[thelittleprince]

Jacob will most likely be leaving tomorrow night. I really can't watch his performances anymore. Makes me cringe when he emotes too much. Haley was the best tonight, IMO, especially with her second song. Still picking James for the win with Scotty as runner-up!

[WyldeMan45]

Jacob and Scotty get the fast forward on every performance every week from me, can't stand either, but James and Haley are incredible. I hate 30 Seconds to Mars so I wasn't a fan of James first performance, but he really brought it home with his second. Haley performing one of my all-time favorite with her Animals cover, was beautiful. She gave me the chills, that song always has that effect on me and she was just perfect. I would love those two to be the finals with James winning, and Haley still going on to be a huge star. As for everybody else, well they can go home I wouldn't buy their stuff, hell I wouldn't even download it, lol.

[Blu_Ray_Addict]

I'm gonna go with James Durbin. This guy is incredible. I thought he did well tonight but not as good as last week's performance. He should still be safe tomorrow. Jacob will finally go home. I hope.

[CZAR]

Originally Posted by WyldeMan45

Jacob and Scotty get the fast forward on every performance every week from me, can't stand either, but James and Haley are incredible. I hate 30 Seconds to Mars so I wasn't a fan of James first performance, but he really brought it home with his second. Haley performing one of my all-time favorite with her Animals cover, was beautiful. She gave me the chills, that song always has that effect on me and she was just perfect. I would love those two to be the finals with James winning, and Haley still going on to be a huge star. As for everybody else, well they can go home I wouldn't buy their stuff, hell I wouldn't even download it, lol.

Glad to see u giving the show a chance. Its a fun show and I fully agree with u about Haley no doubt and even James also. Those two should be in the finale easily. Haley has the full package and she is gorgeous as well. She will be a superstar!!!! I also think Jacob will be going home and still dont see all the love they give Scotty. He is good but not how they make it out to be. Go Haley!!!!! Got Em!!