Component out for Video and HDMI to reciever for sound?

[STOCK1SC]

Is it possible to have the video out from the PS3 as component and assign the HDMI as audio only to the reciever? I have an older RCA HDTV and it only has Component inputs. I was wondering if I bought a new reciever that has HDMI inputs if I could send the audio out to it using the HDMI but still be able to use the component out at the same time? Basically I want to run component to the TV and HDMI to the reciver at the same time. Some people have told me you can't do this and others have said you can. I didn't want to waste the money on a new HDMI reciever if I can't get the HD ausio tracks to work. I know I can't convert HDMi to component and I'm not trying to do that, I just want to hear the new HD surround formats. Thanks!

[un4gvn94538]

you can run the audio and video through seperate cables. what you cant do is run video through both at the same time or audio through two cables at the same time

[Pelican170]

Originally Posted by STOCK1SC

Is it possible to have the video out from the PS3 as component and assign the HDMI as audio only to the reciever? I have an older RCA HDTV and it only has Component inputs. I was wondering if I bought a new reciever that has HDMI inputs if I could send the audio out to it using the HDMI but still be able to use the component out at the same time? Basically I want to run component to the TV and HDMI to the reciver at the same time. Some people have told me you can't do this and others have said you can. I didn't want to waste the money on a new HDMI reciever if I can't get the HD ausio tracks to work. I know I can't convert HDMi to component and I'm not trying to do that, I just want to hear the new HD surround formats. Thanks!

Im pretty sure you can with the ps3, but why would you want to? Component will only give you 1080i...vs 1080p with hdmi...

[aramis109]

Because one works for his tv, and the other doesn't. Did you read the post?

OP, personally I'd maybe look at investing in a new HDTV before the receiver. I had some old RCA HDTV's (member of the family works there and we got them super cheap) and... well, they're not so good. I've had 3 or 4 different models and am now on an LCD via HDMI and there is a world of difference. I would recommend the set first and then consider the receiver.

[Pelican170]

Originally Posted by aramis109

Because one works for his tv, and the other doesn't. Did you read the post?

OP, personally I'd maybe look at investing in a new HDTV before the receiver. I had some old RCA HDTV's (member of the family works there and we got them super cheap) and... well, they're not so good. I've had 3 or 4 different models and am now on an LCD via HDMI and there is a world of difference. I would recommend the set first and then consider the receiver.

Ahhh gotcha, easy killer..

[STOCK1SC]

Originally Posted by aramis109

Because one works for his tv, and the other doesn't. Did you read the post?

OP, personally I'd maybe look at investing in a new HDTV before the receiver. I had some old RCA HDTV's (member of the family works there and we got them super cheap) and... well, they're not so good. I've had 3 or 4 different models and am now on an LCD via HDMI and there is a world of difference. I would recommend the set first and then consider the receiver.

Well I've had this TV for 7 years now and it still looks great for what it is, right now it's just until it dies and I get some more money after just getting a new house. It's mainly on the disney channel anyway because of the kids. I would just rather spend the money right now on a $400 reciever than $2k+ on a new TV and a reciever. Thanks for the help. On a side note does the reciever have to be able to decode the HD surround formats or I've heard that the PS3 does this for you and is redundant on the recievers?

[Pelican170]

Originally Posted by STOCK1SC

Well I've had this TV for 7 years now and it still looks great for what it is, right now it's just until it dies and I get some more money after just getting a new house. It's mainly on the disney channel anyway because of the kids. I would just rather spend the money right now on a $400 reciever than $2k+ on a new TV and a reciever. Thanks for the help. On a side note does the reciever have to be able to decode the HD surround formats or I've heard that the PS3 does this for you and is redundant on the recievers?

you are correct. you do not have to have a receiver that can decode the HD format, the PS3 will do it and send via pcm...through HDMI of course.

[Bean79]

Originally Posted by STOCK1SC

Well I've had this TV for 7 years now and it still looks great for what it is, right now it's just until it dies and I get some more money after just getting a new house. It's mainly on the disney channel anyway because of the kids. I would just rather spend the money right now on a $400 reciever than $2k+ on a new TV and a reciever. Thanks for the help. On a side note does the reciever have to be able to decode the HD surround formats or I've heard that the PS3 does this for you and is redundant on the recievers?

The PS3 can do it. I have a Sony STRDG720 and it works great with the new HD sound. Plus it was only $249.

[STOCK1SC]

Originally Posted by Bean79

The PS3 can do it. I have a Sony STRDG720 and it works great with the new HD sound. Plus it was only $249.

Yeah I think I'm going to buy the Onkyo 606 I saw someone on here bought one at Circuit City for $349. Thanks for the help everyone.

[crackinhedz]

Originally Posted by STOCK1SC

Is it possible to have the video out from the PS3 as component and assign the HDMI as audio only to the reciever? I have an older RCA HDTV and it only has Component inputs.

yes.

I also have an older RCA, does yours have a DVI connection also? (what model is it?)

[Footloose301]

Just be aware that many players will NOT allow you to run both component and HDMI at the same time. A copyright protection screen usually appears. Perhaps you'll be lucky though.

[crackinhedz]

Just be aware that many players will NOT allow you to run both component and HDMI at the same time.

PS3 does it just fine.

[masob98]

Originally Posted by Footloose301

Just be aware that many players will NOT allow you to run both component and HDMI at the same time. A copyright protection screen usually appears. Perhaps you'll be lucky though.

Yeah it works just fine. That's how i have mine setup, but I have DVI hook up. I have an HDMI to DVI for video and Optical to my receiver.

[SkillzthatKillz]

just go to "display settings" under "settings" on the ps3's XMB menu. then assign the video out to "component." then it will ask if you want to assign the audio settings. set it to output of "hdmi" and you should be set. i've had my ps3 outputting of multiple outputs when i took it to my friends house one time

[STOCK1SC]

Originally Posted by crackinhedz

yes.

I also have an older RCA, does yours have a DVI connection also? (what model is it?)

It's the RCA 38" HDTV picture tube with built in Direct Tv reciever. I think it weighs in around 230lb's, you don't want to move it very often.

[aramis109]

Sounds similar to what mine was, though instead of direct TV it had a built in sub. Thing was literally 170lbs.

Well, if you decide you want to go receiver first for sure, then definitely do that. You can't go wrong with an Onkyo or Yamaha or Marantz at that price range. Just make sure it's not HDMI passthrough as those won't get your HD sound from the PS3. If you pick out a model and post it I'm sure folks here can help you decide if it's a good purchase.

Since your budget didn't mention speakers, what kind of setup do you currently have?

Oh, and just for the record, I'm not trying to bash your TV set. I just wanted to let you know there was better out there. We all have to make choices for where we are and our budget. I used RCA for many years (even without HD content on it outside of my xbox 360).

[STOCK1SC]

Originally Posted by aramis109

Sounds similar to what mine was, though instead of direct TV it had a built in sub. Thing was literally 170lbs.

Well, if you decide you want to go receiver first for sure, then definitely do that. You can't go wrong with an Onkyo or Yamaha or Marantz at that price range. Just make sure it's not HDMI passthrough as those won't get your HD sound from the PS3. If you pick out a model and post it I'm sure folks here can help you decide if it's a good purchase.

Since your budget didn't mention speakers, what kind of setup do you currently have?

Oh, and just for the record, I'm not trying to bash your TV set. I just wanted to let you know there was better out there. We all have to make choices for where we are and our budget. I used RCA for many years (even without HD content on it outside of my xbox 360).

I have a brand new 46" Sony Bravia upstairs that has HDMI, i just didn't have the money to buy another one for the basement right now and the RCA is just too big to put in that room plus it's over 230lb's and downstairs, I'm not moving it again. The living room upstairs wasn't big enough for a home theater and the RCA is just something the kids can watch cartoons on during the day. I have the Polk 7200 speaker setup. It sounds good to me, got it 7 years ago as well. I had my basement finished out and set up for a projector and 7.1 but again just waiting for the funds to buy those things. The RCA is just a stop gap for the basement until i get the projector. Later on i might update the RCA when it dies but for now 1080i is fine with me.