Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[indy7solo]

There is like a 5% chance the no and dragon sounds are legit. They sound like cheap overlays over the audio track.

Relax people, let someone get their hands on it legitimately before we kick up a storm. Didn't LOTR EE teach you anything.

[iamsometal]

Originally Posted by Jumpman

So, someone over at theforce.net has a synced clip up on youtube for the Vader moment from Episode VI.

Having seen it synced, it's actually not bad....

You're right, it's not bad, it's a total effing disgrace.

[Jumpman]

While I don't necessarily hate the new "No, NOOOOOO" and will not be deterred from buying it, it is completely unnecessary. The old mantra "actions speak louder than words" is what made this scene great. Vader's actions demonstrate that he has had a change of heart, and he doesn't want to see his son die, so he saves him. The additional line change totally cheapens this, but overall, I'm just annoyed by this, not outraged. It's still fundamentally the same damn movie, so as I said, I'll still be getting this.

That's kind of where I am on this.

[miniroll32]

Originally Posted by teamneedle

new vadar "no no" audio in jedi

originally posted on millenniumfalcon by Duke

http://bayfiles.com/file/RTz/P45etn/NooooNoooo.mp3

and its terrible.

doesn't even sound like OT Vadar- sounds like PT + robot chicken Vadar

Oh... my... freaking... god...

That is pathetic. What the hell is running through George's mind? Does he literally just sit there and think

Hmmm, new release coming up.... What can I change? What can I change.... We have to change something... of COURSE! I originally intended to have Vader go "No... NoOooOooOo!" at the end of Return of The Jedi. Lets get to the studio!

Facepalm. I'm actually laughing out loud because the guy can't keep his hands off these movies. I mean can you seriously imagine Hayden Christensen saying that?

[Ernest Rister]

The new Krayt Dragon scream inspires many chuckles. Can't wait for someone to make a video for that.

[Blu-man08]

Originally Posted by killermike2178

While I don't necessarily hate the new "No, NOOOOOO" and will not be deterred from buying it, it is completely unnecessary. The old mantra "actions speak louder than words" is what made this scene great. Vader's actions demonstrate that he has had a change of heart, and he doesn't want to see his son die, so he saves him. The additional line change totally cheapens this, but overall, I'm just annoyed by this, not outraged. It's still fundamentally the same damn movie, so as I said, I'll still be getting this.

Yeah, I'm with you. I'm not thrilled over it, [Ken Kraley] but it's still going to be great to have Star Wars the Complete Saga on Blu-Ray on September 16![/Ken] Just funnin' ya, Kenny!

[NMR1723]

Originally Posted by Beast

Eh. The "Nooooo" of Vader's on RotJ doesn't bug me. Fits the scene well enough.

I'll wait until I can hear it on the Blu-ray to really judge how it sounds. Not some audio file on the net.

[Show spoiler]Darth Vader's 'Nooo!' in Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi (Supposed Blu-Ray Clip) - YouTube

The first "No" I don't care for as much. It's still cold and emotionless. But the "Nooooo" seems to kind of work. Like it's Vader's "Humanity" resurfacing.

But the more I watch it, I kind of like that the first "No" is so cold and emotionless. Like someone groggily coming to their senses.

That...is awful. I'm still getting the set since I got a deal...but that is just awful.

[meehan]

Help me Adywan. You're my only hope.

[Jumpman]

The problem with changing one's mind from definitely a purchase to question whether to purchase when it comes to Blu Ray is what I call "the Blu Ray Sheen".

Over the last 10 pages, I've actually started questioning whether I'm buying this thing or not. But, I know me. Once the real reviews hit and the talk of picture/audio quality being stunning and then seeing them for myself and I get hooked by the "Sheen", I'll know I'll bite...even as the minutes pass by and that Vader audio clip is starting to make me upset at Lucas for the very first time.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by NMR1723

That...is awful. I'm still getting the set since I got a deal...but that is just awful.

Eh. It's not like Vader's crying and shouting... "Leave Luke alone! Leave him alone!"

[Geoff D]

Originally Posted by Falaskan

As The Emperor was frying Luke, I remember being amazed at how much emotion was conveyed through Vader, and of course you couldn't see any facial expressions!

Yup, it's quite amazing how much of Vader's struggle we can fill in with our imagination. Now, we're being force-fed (heh) Vader's change of heart and Lucas once again shits over the fans from a very great height. Tosser.

[ninjastar2120]

I can live with the "Noooooo.." but that new Krayyt Dragon yell is just awful. It took me a few minutes of listening to the audio before I was able to control my laughter. The original and special edition versions were great so why in the world would this particular scene need any enhancement?

[Chiyo_chichi]

Originally Posted by indy7solo

There is like a 5% chance the no and dragon sounds are legit. They sound like cheap overlays over the audio track.

Relax people, let someone get their hands on it legitimately before we kick up a storm. Didn't LOTR EE teach you anything.

So within hours of new changes been learned (Ewok eyes), somebody decided to take advantage by overlaying never-heard Vader voices on Jedi to have fun with people. Because someone would have easy access to that.

Best to get over the denial now, man.

[iamsometal]

Originally Posted by meehan

Help me Adywan. You're my only hope.

+1!

[nathan_393]

Oh, this is starting to get humorous.

The whole "no" thing is really out of place. But I'm not going to lie to everybody...

[Show spoiler]They're just movies.

[miniroll32]

I'm beginning to question whether this set is worth £67 afterall. I may just keep the Bonus Discs, sell the rest of the Complete Saga and then buy the Original Trilogy. Problem solved!

[kingkong650]

New krayt dragon audio: http://bayfiles.com/file/RQD/3axPN7/KrayytDragon.mp3

krayyt sounds like one of the jackass guys with his balls in a vice

Don´t know who said this but damn if that isn´t an accurate description of this audio. lol

[DarthMarino]

Originally Posted by Chiyo_chichi

So within hours of new changes been learned (Ewok eyes), somebody decided to take advantage by overlaying never-heard Vader voices on Jedi to have fun with people. Because someone would have easy access to that.

Best to get over the denial now, man.

Not to mention that the stupid dragon sound was posted months ago as it was in an official sounds of Star Wars book. It's identical to how it was in that book and the old video and this should be no surprise to anyone who's been following this release.

[nmycon]

Originally Posted by nathan_393

They're just movies.

Yes, they're just movies...

They're just movies that most of us have already invested several hundred dollars in, counting all previous iterations, hoping that the films will be improved with each release

Well they're not being improved, the resolution is better, but every 5 years or so we are getting more unwanted changes and additions and old "mistakes" are not being fixed.

[gadsilla]

If all the changes are true, Wicket's eye blinks, Vader's nooo! etc. I will still be buying them but will not really be so enthusiastic like i was before....