Should Amazon stop showing reviews of the DVD when you click on a Blu-ray title?

[4K2K]

Originally Posted by bluflu

No. Keep them combined. Too many dumb comments from bitter HD DVD fanboys when they're seperate. One reason I don't waste my time reading them.

So even when they list all the extras or whatever on the disc and you think "that sounds great" only to find out the Blu-ray has none of those extras and the only review that is actually for the Blu-ray is the 121st review in the list? Won't you be a bit unhappy about getting something because you thought it was good value especially with all the features listed or because the review said it would work in your region but they were talking about the DVD? Or you read a Blu-ray review but the features listed are from a different release of the Blu-ray with features that aren't on the product you are viewing?

[bluflu]

Originally Posted by 4K2K

So even when they list all the extras or whatever on the disc and you think "that sounds great" only to find out the Blu-ray has none of those extras and the only review that is actually for the Blu-ray is the 121st review in the list? Won't you be a bit unhappy about getting something because you thought it was good value especially with all the features listed or because the review said it would work in your region but they were talking about the DVD? Or you read a Blu-ray review but the features listed are from a different release of the Blu-ray with features that aren't on the product you are viewing?

I see your point. In the beginning, Amazon did have separate reviews for just about every Blu-ray and it was a disaster. Now sometimes they have separate reviews and sometimes they don't. The opinions on Amazon can't be trusted which in turn gives them little value.

Perhaps things might be different postwar. Knowing how things use to be, I'd still say keep the listings separate, but combine the reviews.

[Sky_Captain]

They should also stop little a-holes from posting "DVD RULZ, BLUE RAY SUCKZ!!"