I've had it with Millcreek

[joonskeezle]

Originally Posted by RillIris

The only point I’m making that is what you seem to disagree with is that concentric scratches are fairly (common) in non stacked cases also.

And I'm saying they aren't. I'm not saying I don't think they are, I'm saying they aren't. You've gone on and on and on about spindles and shipping and whatever to try and justify such scratches being common in non-stacker cases but the fact is they just are not. If I went disc-by-disc through my entire blu ray collection right now, I wager I could count on a single hand the number of non-stacker discs I own that have even a small concentric scratch. Parks and Rec would require multiple hands just on its own, nevermind the other stackers I have.

But you've also gone ahead and moved the goalposts in order to downplay the severity of concentric scratches in non-stackers so maybe if I keep pointing out you're wrong you'll just concede that they're extremely rare in non-stackers and extremely common in stackers, and that there is a very specific reason for this: stackers cause concentric scratches.

Whatever quirks of manufacturing or shipping or storage you want to wrestle into this discussion, the demonstrable fact is that stacker cases cause concentric scratches, and that discs are much MUCH more likely to get concentric scratches in stackers than non-stackers.