DUNE (Remake)

[Steve]

I've seen both the original version (and the extended version) and the mini-series. I thought both were very good, but quite different. I've heard that neither really follows the book very well though. I have a copy of the novel, and might get around to reading it one day.

[Lord_Stewie]

I don't know about the miniseries. I just saw the movie recently and liked it. I think the remake is going to suck. just imagine 15 years from now, and FOX starts talking Star Wars Remakes.

[Brandon]

Originally Posted by fireman325

I've seen both the original version (and the extended version) and the mini-series. I thought both were very good, but quite different. I've heard that neither really follows the book very well though. I have a copy of the novel, and might get around to reading it one day.

I don't remember the original movie being that much different than the book, other than the fact that the book was a LOT more complex of course. Like someone else said, it could fit into 3 movies easily. The actual story line is way more epic than the original Star Wars Trilogy. The main difference I remember is that the Baron in the book was not disgustingly diseased like he was in the movie, that was a David Lynch special right there.