3D Effects: Popping Out or Poppping in? - Discussion

[Yourbigpalal83]

I for one think it all depends on the scene. I think if you poke people in the eye too much in a 3d movie with stuff constantly poping out at you it looses the reality of the shot.

I mean, honestly how often in real life is someone jabbing a finger or object at you going "Your seeing this in 3d!" Not to often, (at least i dont)

To me, the whole point of 3d is to get you into the world of the movie! To make it feel real, to not be just a rapid sucession of images on a flat screen, but to make it feel like a real vivid world with its own reality.

Jabbing you in the eye constantly is going to kill that illusion. Depth of field will sell it more.