BDA- Calling you out

[neo_reloaded]

Originally Posted by OokieSpookie

Because they can does not mean they should.
All movies can legitimately fit on a dvd too and all movies fit rather well on hd-dvd also.

I said "legitimately," implying "fit with enough space so that audio and video do not suffer." Not every movie needs a BD-25, and making some strawman argument to link it to DVD or HD DVD is absurd.

Yes, there are movies that benefit from BD-50s, absolutely. Longer movies, movies with lots of HD special features, etc. do need a BD-50 to not be cramped. But if a movie is an hour and a half or so, and has SD or a small amount of HD special features, a BD-25 can be plenty.

Go look at Doomsday. 113 minute movie, DTS-HD MA soundtrack, U-Control PiP, and an absolutely beautiful transfer. All on a BD-25.