I, Robot question regarding U.S. or UK release

[svander]

Originally Posted by Sky_Captain

If you're going to be a smart-ass, then at least quote something reliable.
As Jeff said, I' Robot has a very fine grain structure and let's not forget that *shock* it was actually shot on film.

Not being a smart ass - just have an issue with people asking for answers and expecting them in a silver platter without doing research themselves and then coping an attitude here. Examples:

Originally Posted by QQQQ!

I can read, I know two people already wrote
that they didn't remember any grain

Originally Posted by QQQQ!

You can't ask me a question I asked for, that's why I don't have the answer.

Originally Posted by QQQQ!

I wasn't asking what reference quality means, but thanks anyway.

See what I'm saying?

And the review I quoted was the one hosted here, written by Martin Liebman. If you don't consider his review to be reliable, well... I'm sorry.

The film is not grainy; wasn't meant to be or shot to have it (a la Bourne Trilogy for example) and the transfer is very faithful to the original; naturally it will have some - like you accurately pointed out, it was shot on Super 35 but beyond that, it's very smooth looking, even for a film-shot motion picture.