Star Wars: The Complete Saga (1977-2005)

[BR7]

Wow ! I had to watch A New Hope first. I am extremely pleased with the picture and sound quality. I have one gripe. There is a red line on the right side of the picture that stays there. It's not the tv or my ps3 cause I tested it. I think somebody at skywalker ranch goofed.It seems to go away around the time he cleans the droids.

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by happydood

Let's act reasonably. That would be like saying you have John Goodman as your avatar, therefore I'll assume you have a shrine to the Rosanne show in your living room.

I haven't spent hundreds of pages defending and rationalizing everything John Goodman has ever done. That's the big difference. His avatar has nothing to do with it.

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

George Lucas is NOT in court! No Filmmaker is (except maybe Roman Polanski)... It's a sad world where consumers suddenly know more about a film than the writer/director/producer. Why must every change be defended, why even have an opinion on each and every change? Do you question each and every scene in every movie? Because most scenes are products of some kind of compromise where it could have played one or the other way... And in my opinion a guy who has single handedly created such a vast and complex narrative has earned the right to revise his work! Can't you give him that? It's his lifes work!

The question was "how could technology possibly be an excuse for Vader not saying NOOO originally?"

Your righteous indignation is appreciated and might sway a lesser man, but it doesn't work as a deflector shield to seasoned veterans of internet debates.

I'm gonna surmise that you don't have an explanation for how technology could be to blame for this particular change.

[nmycon]

originally, it was posted on Wikipedia that Han no longer says "you could use a good kiss"

I couldn't believe it, so I watched my copy, sure enough, he said it. So I changed the article. It was even there in the subtitles.

[Mavrick]

Originally Posted by BR7

Wow ! I had to watch A New Hope first. I am extremely pleased with the picture and sound quality. I have one gripe. There is a red line on the right side of the picture that stays there. It's not the tv or my ps3 cause I tested it. I think somebody at skywalker ranch goofed.

Someone posted erlier that there was a green line screen right,

[Darth Lover]

I don't have sound system just yet. Don't have the money for one. Maybe that is what's wrong

[Mavrick]

Originally Posted by nmycon

originally, it was posted on Wikipedia that Han no longer says "you could use a good kiss"

I couldn't believe it, so I watched my copy, sure enough, he said it. So I changed the article. It was even there in the subtitles.

Thanks for changing it. I hate misinformation being spread like that!

[Bluyoda]

Originally Posted by iamsometal

Afraid not. Watched the entire Jedi blu-ray. The NO still ruins the climax of the film (and ultimately, the entire series).

And nope, Ep.I-VI order does NOT miraculously work beautifully, as Ep.I-III are still dreadfully aweful movies.

Originally Posted by greg_achen

Where have you gotten that impression? I have heard a few people say that they don't mind the addition after seeing it in context of the film, but that's hardly "most" people and being indifferent to it is not the same as outright liking it, which I haven't seen too many people claim aside from the usual suspects.

I have been reading the thread since the BD release, and most people said that they liked it after seeing the whole movie.
That's a fact, and it once again proves that the outcry was way over the top, and uncalled for. It's a very fitting change IMO.

Originally Posted by dcowboy7

My bluray still has the old yoda puppet in ep1.

You are kidding, right?

Speaking of which:

The new Yoda in TPM is absolutely incredible!!!
His performance is genius!!! I LOVE him!!!!!
Wish they used that model for AOTC too.

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by Darth Lover

I don't have sound system just yet. Don't have the money for one. Maybe that is what's wrong

I use a cheap Altec Lansing PC speaker setup and it's there for me.

Maybe you have your TV's sound settings to something they can't handle. Switch it to stereo.

[Mavrick]

Originally Posted by Darth Lover

I don't have sound system just yet. Don't have the money for one. Maybe that is what's wrong

Ahh that might be it then.

[BR7]

Originally Posted by Mavrick

Someone posted erlier that there was a green line screen right,

mine is red

[Shaft Windu]

Originally Posted by El_Jay

I haven't spent hundreds of pages defending and rationalizing everything John Goodman has ever done. That's the big difference. His avatar has nothing to do with it.



The question was "how could technology possibly be an excuse for Vader not saying NOOO originally?"

Your righteous indignation is appreciated and might sway a lesser man, but it doesn't work as a deflector shield to seasoned veterans of internet debates.

I'm gonna surmise that you don't have an explanation for how technology could be to blame for this particular change.

I DID say: technology was not to blame! Lucas probably had the idea while reviewing the movies for the blu-ray release! And why not!? He has the right to do so! Like I said: He is not in court!

[octagon]

Originally Posted by Shaft Windu

And in my opinion a guy who has single handedly created such a vast and complex narrative has earned the right to revise his work!

Single-handedly?

Seriously?

[MCT]

I showed my mom the Noooo scene and she started cracking up....loudly. "man! Why did Lucas do that?"

All I could do was shake my head and shrug.

[wormraper]

Originally Posted by MCT

I showed my mom the Noooo scene and she started cracking up....loudly. "man! Why did Lucas do that?"

All I could do was shake my head and shrug.

lol, I showed the Krayt dragon scene and Noooooooooooooooo scene to a couple of friends who haven't been keeping up with all the internet debate their reactions were the same... "are you kidding me!!!"

[Mavrick]

Originally Posted by BR7

mine is red

and on the left? Or the right? Because the green line is on the right and it's visable in the screenshot taken by this very site.



It is barely visable and I never noticed it whilst watching. Yours is the first I've heard of a red line though.

[BR7]

Originally Posted by Mavrick

and on the left? Or the right? Because the green line is on the right and it's visable in the screenshot taken by this very site.



It is barely visable and I never noticed it whilst watching. Yours is the first I've heard of a red line though.

as im facing the tv it would be on my right. It looks red to me

[Weirded Wonder]

Originally Posted by Bluyoda

I have been reading the thread since the BD release, and most people said that they liked it after seeing the whole movie.
That's a fact, and it once again proves that the outcry was way over the top, and uncalled for. It's a very fitting change IMO.



You are kidding, right?

Speaking of which:

The new Yoda in TPM is absolutely incredible!!!
His performance is genius!!! I LOVE him!!!!!
Wish they used that model for AOTC too.

Somebody needs to create a poll on the changes of Darth Vader's "NO-NO" and Obi-Wan's "Dragon Attack".

I was thinking instead of Vader saying No, he should have said "nuh-uh-uh" while shaking his finger at the Emperor and then says "Palpee, you have a lotta splainin to do".

[Darth Lover]

Yeah,no sound system is the problem. Thanks everyone for your help. I got to start saving money for me a good system!

[Radical Ed]

Originally Posted by dcowboy7

My bluray still has the old yoda puppet in ep1.

My Ep. IV Bluray still has Greedo shooting first, among other things.

[Meathead]

mine arrived today

watching Episode I TPM,so far the PQ and AQ are fantastic